In reviewing the life of Shaul (King Saul,) I think of his story as a tragedy in the classical Greek sense, i.e. a noble hero with a tragic flaw that undoes him. In Shaul’s case, I think of his flaw as a lack of respect. He did not respect the monarchy enough to defend it against slanderers early in his reign, or to uphold several oaths he as king had made. He did not respect the Shmuel’s instructions to wait for the prophet be present to make a sacrifice, or later to wipe out Amalek. And he did not respect God’s decision, through Shmuel, to revoke his monarchy, and went down fighting.