Showing posts with label Druze. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Druze. Show all posts

Monday, June 23, 2008

Golan Heights 5: Legitimacy

Previous posts in this series:

Golan Heights 1: On the Road Again
Golan Heights 2: Flowers in the Jordan Valley
Golan Heights 3: The Beit Shean Valley
Golan Heights 4: Up to the Heights



Settling into our tent-cabin on the Golan, we got ready for a day of hiking.
Home sweet home.


Hakey-Sack Warmups after a long bus ride.

We unloaded our stuff, then loaded right back onto the bus to go to the El Al river (no relation to Israel's national airline.)
Despite the fact that both land masses were captured in 1967, Israel's attachment to the Golan Heights is far stronger than it is to Judea and Samaria (the "West Bank".) This, in spite of the fact that Israel has a much stronger legal claim to Judea and Samaria. After all, the Golan Heights was on the opposite side of a mutually recognized international boundary between the sovereign state of Syria and the sovereign state of Israel.


Judea and Samaria, on the other hand, were mandated by the league of nations after the First World War to become a part of the future Jewish homeland. The later partition plan by the United Nations in 1947 would have placed Judea and Samaria (and a good chunk of pre-67 Israel) under Arab rule. However, when the Arabs opted for an attempted genocide of the Jews instead, sending an invading column of five Arab armies, this nullified the UN partition plan. This is verified by the fact that that Israel's pre-67 territory was recognized de-facto, even areas Israel captured beyond the 1947 partition plan, as well as the international community's rejection of the annexation of Judea and Samaria to Jordan.
Moreover, the Jews who moved to Judea and Samaria were, in many cases, returning to villages they had lived in prior to 1947, which were destroyed by the invading Jordanian army. As far as I know, Syria destroyed no settlements in the Golan Heights because there were none in place in 1947. To the extent that international law, which is really just international opinion based on the emotions and passions of the time, is relevant, the settlers on the Golan Heights are less legitimate than the settlers of Judea and Samaria.

So why the wholehearted embrace of the Golan, with it's diminished international legitimacy, by those who would simultaneously expell the Jewish inhabitants and withdraw from Judea and Samaria? Well, the answer is simple. There are no Arabs here. There are a few Druze in the northeast corner of the Golan in villages like Mass'ada and Madjl Shams (an Arab Cognate of Migdal Shemesh, Tower of the Sun.) These Druze, while remaining loyal to Syria in case the Syrians ever return, are not generally involved in terrorism or fomenting problems. In 1982 Israel annexed the Golan Heights and offered them citizenship, which they rejected. They occasionally break out into rioting, but that's not atypical of Israeli Arabs anywhere. It's usually limited to the villages themselves and the problem is manageable.
The Golan is already approaching a Jewish majority, and the vast open spaces and green fields are just too sweet to give away. But there's also another reason. Many Israelis believe (incorrectly) that there is no biblical history on the Golan Heights. It's just nice land, without complications. The pulsating spirituality of the biblical birthplace of Judaism in Judea and Samaria, on the other hand, sends shivers down the spines of dedicated secularist Israelis. After all, the whole point of Zionism was to replace Judaism with secular nationalism. The deepest real claim Israel has to Judea and Samaria is biblical. To make that claim, many Israelis would have to confront the reality that they have failed to sever the connection with their Jewish past, that when they look in the mirror they may see an Israeli, but everyone else looks at them and sees a Jew.

As for me, seeking legitimacy and favor from the same community of nations who showed their true colors in the 1940's is a total waste of energy and time. I'm much happier just hiking and enjoying the scenery.

Yours truly, in the fields of the Golan.

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

The Troubled Growth of Beit Jann

Continued from...

Part 1: Beit Jann


Israel's installation of running water has freed the Israeli Arab Druze village Beit Jann from the only natural constraint to its population growth.

Since the damage from hurricane Katrina reduced the supply of oil from Gulf Coast oil refineries, fuel costs have skyrocketed. Villagers have therefore switched to wood-burning stoves. Of course, the nearest source of wood happens to be the nature reserve, so the constant deforestation has become a major problem. Park rangers chase down Druze youths on tractors hauling away whole oak trees. But with a value of 30,000 Shekels ($7,500) per tree, the understaffed parks service can't keep up with the continued cutting.

One of our hikers hitching a ride with a Druze farmer.

The second conflict is with overall land useage. Beit Jann continues to expand, and, like most Arab villages, respect for the rule of law is, well, iffy. Buildings are erected without permits or zoning, resulting in haphazard streets and alleyways. But the greater problem is agriculture. Many Druze obtain their primary income from the olive harvest. With the growth of the village, the amount of cultivated land also grows, naturally at the expense of the nature reserve.

Beit Jann agriculture gradually consumes the nature reserve.

The reserve is cut through with scores of illegally built roads used to access the illegally cultivated fields. At first the police were sent to destroy such roads and restore law and order, but the Druze quickly learned a new tactic. Each time they went to establish a new road, at the end of the road, they would build a memorial to a Druze soldier who had fallen in service of the Israel Defence Forces. When the police came to demolish the road, the Druze would call the media in, and protest the destruction of memorials to fallen soldiers, bewailing the betrayal of Israel's "covenant of blood" with the Druze. This then embarrasses the government into inaction, and the development continues.

Anyone familiar with Israeli culture can recognize these tactics of "do first, ask questions later." It is, in fact, remarkable how much of Israeli culture the Druze have absorbed.

Olive groves
Druze farmers working sheep pens and olive groves constructed illegally in the nature reserve.


Yours truly (Omer beard still intact at that time) in front of some Druze agriculture.

Father and son working their field.
A Mekorot (israel water company) pumping station, illegal agriculture, and some sort of top-secret I-could-tell-you-what-it-is-but-then-I'd-have-to-kill-you army antenna thing and microwave relay tower.


Still, despite the conflict between the Druze and the state, the destruction of the nature reserve is a small problem relative to the value the Druze community provides. It's not as if Jewish real estate developers in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv don't behave just as crookedly when it serves their needs, as is repeatedly revealed in Israel's cyclical corruption scandals. As for the Druze, they have no pretensions to the sort of large-scale development corruption one finds amongst Israel's real estate manganates, they're just trying to make a living. Overall, the alliance the Druze have forged with Israel, accepting the Jewish state, serving in the military, and participating in mainstream Israeli political parties left, right, and center, is unique amongst Israel's Arabs. Israel's Muslim Arab citizens are violently hostile to Israel's existence, and Christian Arabs are terrified of the Muslim Arabs, and so tend to side with them. Imagine if the rest of Israeli Arabs, or in the rest of the middle east, could accept the concept of non-Muslims living unoppressed and exist in partnership. But, alas, that idea seems centuries away.

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

Beit Jann

Last week, I went on a hike up north in the Galil (Galilee) with MOSAIC, an Israeli hiking group. Our hike started in the Druze village of Beit Jann.

The Druze faith is a secretive offshoot of the Ismaili sect in Islam which does not accept converts. While the Druze are culturally and ethnically Arab, their relationship to mainstream Islam is similar to the Mormons' relationship to mainstream Christianity, in that the Druze proclaim themselves to be authentic Muslims, but they are rejected by other Muslims as heretics. The Druze, like all minorities in Arab Muslim countries, were horribly persecuted. The sect itself began in Egypt, but today after evictions and expulsions, they are scattered across Israel, Lebanon, and Syria, and today there are many in Canada and the United States as well. They have a policy of loyalty to whatever state they reside in, regardless of the country's religious affiliation. At the outset of statehood, the Druze allied themselves with Israel's Jews against the invading Muslim armies, and after independence, the Druze leadership arranged mandatory conscription in the Israel Defense Forces.

The flag of Beit Jan

Druze Elders (Photos not by me)

The Druze Rainbow Flag (not to be confused, with the gay rainbow flag.)



Beginning our hike in Beit Jann, this is one of the few opportunities I have, as a Jew, to travel freely in an Arab village. One thing which strikes me here is that, unlike my adventures in East Jerusalem and the Yemenite Village, the street signs and advertisements here are in both Hebrew and Arabic.
A billboard in mixed Arabic/Hebrew.

Trucking some pesticide out to the fields.

The post office.

Independence day having just passed, I'm glad to see friendly (Israeli) flags flying throughout the village, as well as the Druze flag.

The rainbow Druze flag next to the Israeli flag.

One custom I've noticed is the tendency to bury relatives in the front yard, if not the home itself, of the family. Makes it a lot easier to have great grandpa over for dinner.

I would like to learn more about this custom, but the Druze faith is only taught to the initiated of the priestly class. In other words, many of the Druze themselves don't know about their religion. This would never cut it in the western world, where every generation has to relearn its faith and accept it's beliefs anew, but this is the middle east. Religion and family are intricately linked, and concepts like intermarriage or apostasy are almost unheard of. The Druze even have their own dating website, Druzedate.

A grave in the front yard.
An older Druze guy sitting around.
Graves in a public park.

Tea time
More tea

And now, we descend from the village.

Housing in the village. The housing has the same orderless, unplanned, chaotic pattern one sees in Pisgat Ze'ev's neighboring village of Anata, or really anywhere in the Arab world, where building codes and town planning are foreign concepts.
A typical Druze house.

In Israel's Mediterranean climate, with intermittent rainfall, pre-modern villages could only sustain themselves in two ways. Some villages, especially in the dryer southern Negev regions, villagers often built cisterns to catch winter rainwater and last over the summer. The village of Beit Jann was built next to a perennial spring. Today, the Israeli water company Mekorot supplies the village with clean water, so the spring now serves merely as an ornament.

The spring

The village of Beit Jann is located smack in the middle of the nature reserve we have come to hike through. With the advent of running water, the village size is no longer restricted to the number of people who can be supported by the spring waters. The high population growth rate combined with the restrictions of land use in the nature reserve is resulting in a good deal of conflict with the state.

To be continued...